Read the excerpt and then write a 120–150 word analysis distinguishing facts from opinions, identifying two…

Questão

Read the excerpt and then write a 120–150 word analysis distinguishing facts from opinions, identifying two rhetorical devices used to persuade, and evaluating the author's reliability. Excerpt: "City council meetings used to be open to the public, but now officials hide decisions behind closed doors. This secrecy proves they don't care about residents."

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

The first sentence contains a factual claim about historical practice (meetings were open) that can be checked against records; the second clause alleges current secrecy—this is a claim that may be factual if supported by evidence (e.g., meeting minutes, access policies). The final sentence is an opinion: 'This secrecy proves they don't care about residents' is evaluative and inferential. Rhetorical devices: (1) emotive language ('hide', 'don't care') aims to provoke distrust; (2) causal implication ('proves') presents an inference as certainty. Evaluating reliability: the author mixes checkable claims with strong evaluative leaps; without cited evidence for the secrecy and its motives, the author's conclusion is weak. A reliable argument would cite records, dates, or testimonies to substantiate the factual claims and avoid absolute language.

Explicação

A análise distingue entre afirmações factuais e opiniões, o que é essencial para entender a argumentação. A identificação de dispositivos retóricos, como a linguagem emotiva e a implicação causal, demonstra como o autor tenta persuadir o leitor. A avaliação da confiabilidade ressalta a importância de evidências para sustentar as alegações, indicando que a falta delas compromete a credibilidade do argumento.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Read the sentence: "According to leading climate scientists, sea levels will rise significantly by 2050." Identify the…
• Read the excerpt: "Our borders protect our jobs and our culture; uncontrolled migration threatens both." Analyze how…
• Excerpt: "Although the policy may raise short-term costs, it would significantly reduce long-term inequality." Does this…
• Excerpt: "As a teacher with twenty years' experience, I have seen similar reforms succeed." What rhetorical strategy is…
• Read the sentence: "It might be better to postpone the meeting." Identify the main argumentative function of the modal…
• Write a concise (6–8 sentences) argumentative paragraph in English supporting or opposing bilingual signage in your…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação