Plan a concise argumentative essay in English responding to the prompt: 'Public schools should allow students…

Questão

Plan a concise argumentative essay in English responding to the prompt: 'Public schools should allow students to use personal mobile phones during breaks.' Provide: a one-sentence thesis, three supporting arguments each with a specific type of evidence or example, one anticipated counterargument with a brief rebuttal, and a concluding sentence.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Thesis: Public schools should permit student use of personal mobile phones during scheduled breaks because controlled access supports social connection, enables quick parental contact, and provides practical learning opportunities. Support 1 (social): Allowing phones during breaks reduces social isolation; evidence: survey results from local schools showing increased peer interaction when phones are available in non-class times. Support 2 (safety): Phones enable fast contact in emergencies; evidence: documented cases where student or parent calls prevented or managed after-school incidents (school incident reports). Support 3 (learning): Controlled phone use teaches digital responsibility and can support informal learning apps; evidence: classroom pilot projects where supervised app use improved research skills (small-scale study results). Counterargument: Critics say phones distract and encourage misuse during school hours. Rebuttal: A clear policy limiting use to breaks, staff supervision, and consequences for misuse preserves learning time while granting measured benefits. Conclusion: With explicit rules and supervision, permitting phones at breaks balances student well-being, safety, and practical skill development while minimizing disruption.

Explicação

A estrutura da resposta apresenta uma tese clara e argumentos bem fundamentados, cada um apoiado por evidências específicas que fortalecem a posição defendida. A inclusão de um contra-argumento com uma refutação demonstra a capacidade de antecipar objeções e responder a elas de forma lógica. Por fim, a conclusão resume os principais pontos e reafirma a posição, garantindo coesão ao texto.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• In the school forum, Leo wrote: “Phones should stay in lockers during class. I checked messages and missed the…
• — Why should our town fund a repair café? Mr. Cole asked at a fictional council meeting. “Some old phones have weak…
• “Why should our library close at 5 p.m. when many residents finish work later?” asked Maya, a student, during a town…
• Exploring the digital shelves of the Global Literature App, students can access public-domain classics in English. The…
• On a local community forum, two residents discussed the growing number of old phones and broken chargers at home. Mia…
• Read the short opinion paragraph and then write a focused analysis. Paragraph: Many commuters now cycle to work because…

Todas as questões de Reflexão pós-leitura