You will plan an argumentative essay in English on the prompt: “Should secondary schools require a mandatory…

Questão

You will plan an argumentative essay in English on the prompt: “Should secondary schools require a mandatory financial-literacy course for graduation?” Produce: (a) one-sentence thesis; (b) three distinct supporting claims; (c) for each claim, name the exact type of evidence you would seek and one concrete, reliable source to consult; (d) the logical paragraph order; (e) a one-sentence rebuttal to the strongest counterargument and the data source to refute it.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Thesis: Require a mandatory financial-literacy course to teach money management, reduce student debt, and boost career readiness. Evidence: 1) budgeting — national stats (OECD PISA financial literacy report); 2) debt reduction — longitudinal study (Journal of Consumer Affairs); 3) readiness — local district pilot report. Order: Introduction/thesis; Claim1 (skills); Claim2 (debt outcomes); Claim3 (readiness); Rebuttal; Conclusion. Rebuttal: Although critics say curricular time is limited, district pilot evaluations and PISA impact analyses show net academic and life-skill benefits (cite district pilot report or OECD analysis).

Explicação

A estrutura apresentada organiza claramente o argumento em torno da tese principal, com cada reivindicação apoiada por evidências específicas e fontes confiáveis. A ordem lógica dos parágrafos facilita a compreensão do raciocínio, enquanto a refutação aborda uma possível objeção de forma convincente, utilizando dados relevantes. Essa abordagem fortalece a argumentação e demonstra um planejamento eficaz para o ensaio.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Student Council Update Last month, the eco-club counted 480 single-use plastic cups thrown away during one school week…
• At the fictional Northbridge Museum, the council is considering a $3 entrance fee to pay for building repairs. Since…
• Why should a public library change signs that many regular visitors already understand? At the fictional Westbridge…
• Write a 180–220-word article in English for your school's online newsletter arguing for or against making a compulsory…
• Write a 10–12 sentence persuasive comment in English for a school online forum advocating weekly digital-free study…
• Write a concise (8–10 sentences) argumentative forum post in English that takes a clear position for or against…

Todas as questões de Escrita: construção da argumentação