Read the excerpt: "Our town has become unsafe because the new park attracts only troublemakers. Crime rates…

Questão

Read the excerpt: "Our town has become unsafe because the new park attracts only troublemakers. Crime rates have risen since last year by 5%, so the mayor's policies have failed." Identify which clauses are facts and which are opinions, evaluate the author's bias, and explain how selective use of data affects the argument.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: "Crime rates have risen since last year by 5%" is presented as a factual claim but requires source verification; both "the park attracts only troublemakers" and "the mayor's policies have failed" are opinions or value judgments. The author shows negative bias by generalizing from an unverified anecdote (the park) and linking correlation to causation without evidence. Selective use of a single percentage, without baseline, context, timeframe or source, can mislead readers and overstate conclusions. A critical evaluation should request data sources, compare broader crime trends, consider alternative explanations, and distinguish verified statistics from subjective claims.

Explicação

A análise identifica claramente as distinções entre fatos e opiniões, destacando a necessidade de verificação das informações apresentadas. A identificação do viés do autor revela como a generalização e a falta de evidências podem comprometer a credibilidade do argumento. Além disso, a crítica ao uso seletivo de dados enfatiza a importância de considerar o contexto e a fonte das informações para uma avaliação mais precisa.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Read the sentence: "If we do not act now, our children will inherit an unlivable planet." Identify the main…
• Read the excerpt: "Studies show that city commuters waste hours in traffic, proving public transport is inefficient…
• Consider: 'In a survey of 50 forum users, 92% said app X is the best; therefore everyone should switch to app X.'…
• In the claim 'According to Professor Kim, vaccination reduces hospitalization rates,' which argumentative resource…
• Read the sentence: 'This study suggests that climate policies may reduce emissions.' Which argumentative resource is…
• Editorial excerpt: 'Our neighborhood has changed; immigrants bring crime and take jobs.' Write a critical analysis in…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação