Write a 200–230-word argumentative response in English evaluating two potential risks and two benefits of…

Questão

Write a 200–230-word argumentative response in English evaluating two potential risks and two benefits of using English as a neutral medium in international school projects, and propose a brief strategy to reduce one identified risk.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Using English as a neutral medium in international projects offers clear benefits: first, it enables wider participation by providing a common channel for students from diverse linguistic backgrounds, facilitating resource sharing and collaborative learning. Second, it prepares learners for global communication and access to academic and professional opportunities where English is often used. However, there are notable risks. One risk is linguistic inequality: students with stronger English proficiency may dominate discussions and assessment, marginalizing less fluent peers. Another risk is cultural overshadowing, where local languages and perspectives receive less attention, potentially weakening students' cultural identity. To mitigate linguistic inequality, schools can implement targeted language support within projects: provide glossaries, bilingual scaffolds, pair non-native speakers with supportive peers, and assess both content and language separately. This strategy preserves the project's international accessibility while valuing multilingual competence. By combining inclusive pedagogies with explicit language support, educators can harness the practical advantages of English as a shared medium without erasing local identities or disadvantaging less proficient speakers.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta uma análise equilibrada, destacando tanto os benefícios quanto os riscos do uso do inglês em projetos internacionais, o que demonstra uma compreensão crítica do tema. Além disso, a proposta de estratégia para mitigar um dos riscos identificados é prática e viável, mostrando um pensamento reflexivo sobre como melhorar a situação. A estrutura clara e a argumentação lógica contribuem para a efetividade da resposta.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• A travel app team surveys 20 visitors. Eight say English is their first language. Five others say English is an official…
• At an international robotics tournament, teams arrive from Brazil, Japan, and Egypt. Since they speak different first…
• A travel magazine organizes a small chart about English in seven selected countries: Native language: United States…
• English around the world North America - United States: native language Europe - Ireland: native language; Malta…
• In the 19th century, British ships traveled to ports around the world. Merchants often used English to trade with people…
• English was spoken in Britain before British settlers crossed the Atlantic. They brought the language to North America…

Todas as questões de Países que têm a língua inglesa como língua materna e/ou oficial