Excerpt: "The county health board logged a 12% drop in clinic visits after closing two satellite clinics. The…

Questão

Excerpt: "The county health board logged a 12% drop in clinic visits after closing two satellite clinics. The op-ed argues budget cuts reduced access to care and cites longer travel times and appointment delays." Task: In a 180–230 word response, identify the author's main arguments and the evidence or examples used to support each; evaluate the strength of that evidence.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

The author advances two linked claims: that budget cuts reduced access to care and that service changes caused delays. Evidence includes a 12% drop in visits (quantitative) and references to longer travel times and appointment delays (qualitative). The numeric decline is strong empirical support for reduced access; the travel-time and delay examples illustrate mechanisms but need clearer sourcing to fully confirm causation.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente as duas principais alegações do autor e apresenta as evidências que as sustentam, diferenciando entre dados quantitativos e qualitativos. Além disso, faz uma avaliação crítica da força das evidências, destacando a solidez do apoio empírico e a necessidade de mais informações para confirmar a relação de causa e efeito. Essa análise equilibrada demonstra compreensão do texto e habilidade de avaliação crítica.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Excerpt: “Recent municipal health reports show teenage vaping rose from 8% to 21% in five years; hospital admissions for…
• Using the same excerpt above, write a 250–300 word essay in English that analyzes how the author’s lexical choices…
• Analyze the sentence: "Mistakes were made during the implementation of the new language policy." What discursive…
• "Our language is under attack—foreign words are destroying our culture." Which argumentative resource best describes…
• Read the sentence: "As a physician, I recommend this vaccine." Which rhetorical appeal is the speaker using primarily?
• Read: "When English is labeled 'standard,' speakers of other varieties are often treated as less competent. Schools and…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação