Read the editorial excerpt and complete the tasks below. Editorial excerpt: "A recent report from the county…

Questão

Read the editorial excerpt and complete the tasks below. Editorial excerpt: "A recent report from the county water authority recorded that measurable nitrate levels exceeded safety guidelines at three monitoring sites last month. The columnist claims the council's slow response proves the mayor prioritizes development over public health." Tasks: (a) List two factual statements present in the excerpt and explain briefly why each is a fact. (b) State the author's main opinion and indicate two language signals that show it is an opinion.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: (a) Factual statement 1: "A recent report from the county water authority recorded that measurable nitrate levels exceeded safety guidelines at three monitoring sites last month." Reason: it references an identifiable source (county water authority), a measurable substance (nitrate levels), specific sites, and a time period; these are verifiable facts. Factual statement 2: "at three monitoring sites last month." Reason: the number of sites and the time frame are concrete, quantifiable details reported by the authority and can be checked in the report. (b) Author's main opinion: "the mayor prioritizes development over public health." Language signals showing opinion: the phrase "prioritizes development over public health" is an evaluative judgment, and the verb "proves" in the clause "proves the mayor prioritizes" signals the columnist's claim rather than a documented fact. Both elements reflect interpretation and judgment, not independently verifiable data.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta dois fatos que podem ser verificados por meio de fontes confiáveis, como relatórios e dados específicos, o que os caracteriza como informações objetivas. Além disso, a identificação da opinião do autor e os sinais linguísticos que a acompanham demonstram uma análise crítica do texto, evidenciando a diferença entre fato e opinião. Essa abordagem ajuda a entender a intenção do autor e a fundamentar a interpretação do conteúdo apresentado.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• For a class project, a student compares the role of English in two countries. The project notes that English is an…
• A comparative report for a language exhibition presents this fictional survey of residents aged 15 or older: “In…
• During a renovation, a technician writes in a report: “A cold draft entered through a gap beneath the door.” Later, an…
• Em uma reportagem sobre animais, lê-se: “At dusk, a bat flew out of the cave.” Em uma notícia esportiva, aparece: “The…
• At an international sailing event, 18 crews from 12 countries took part. English was the official language for race…
• Editorial excerpt, adapted for educational use from data published by UNESCO in 2024: "UNESCO reported that 251 million…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação