Read the short journalistic paragraph and complete the tasks: "According to the county health department, lead…

Questão

Read the short journalistic paragraph and complete the tasks: "According to the county health department, lead tests in three schools found elevated levels in two classrooms. Attendance records show no increase in reported illnesses. A parent columnist argued that the district has been negligent for years." Identify two factual statements and explain why each is a fact; then identify the opinion and justify your choice.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Factual 1: "Lead tests in three schools found elevated levels in two classrooms." — reports test results and numbers from a named source (verifiable). Factual 2: "Attendance records show no increase in reported illnesses." — cites a record-based statistic (verifiable). Opinion: "The district has been negligent for years." — expresses judgment about responsibility over time and cannot be verified as an objective fact.

Explicação

A identificação das afirmações factuais é baseada na sua capacidade de serem verificadas por dados concretos, como resultados de testes e registros de frequência. A opinião, por outro lado, reflete uma avaliação subjetiva sobre a responsabilidade do distrito, que não pode ser confirmada por evidências objetivas. Essa distinção entre fatos e opiniões é fundamental para a análise crítica de informações.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• For a class project, a student compares the role of English in two countries. The project notes that English is an…
• A comparative report for a language exhibition presents this fictional survey of residents aged 15 or older: “In…
• During a renovation, a technician writes in a report: “A cold draft entered through a gap beneath the door.” Later, an…
• Em uma reportagem sobre animais, lê-se: “At dusk, a bat flew out of the cave.” Em uma notícia esportiva, aparece: “The…
• At an international sailing event, 18 crews from 12 countries took part. English was the official language for race…
• Editorial excerpt, adapted for educational use from data published by UNESCO in 2024: "UNESCO reported that 251 million…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação