Read the short editorial excerpt below (in English). Identify three factual statements and three opinion…

Questão

Read the short editorial excerpt below (in English). Identify three factual statements and three opinion statements. For each factual statement, state one specific source or method you would use to verify it. Excerpt: "City council voted 5–2 to limit overnight deliveries downtown. Noise complaints doubled in the past year, according to the municipal hotline. Many shop owners warn the restriction will harm small businesses and erode customer convenience."

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: Factual statements: 1) "City council voted 5–2 to limit overnight deliveries downtown." — Verifiable: check the city council meeting minutes or official ordinance record. 2) "Noise complaints doubled in the past year, according to the municipal hotline." — Verifiable: request the municipal hotline report or complaint database for counts by year. 3) "...according to the municipal hotline." (the attribution itself is factual that the hotline reported it) — Verifiable via the same hotline records or press release. Opinion statements: 1) "Many shop owners warn the restriction will harm small businesses" — Opinion: expresses a prediction and value judgment from stakeholders. 2) "...will harm small businesses and erode customer convenience." — Opinion: subjective forecast about consequences. 3) (Implicit) The editorial tone that the restriction is negative — Opinion: general evaluative stance. Brief justification: Facts report verifiable events or data (votes, complaint counts, stated sources). Opinions express judgments, predictions, or attitudes and often use evaluative language (harm, erode, warn). Verification methods: consult official records (council minutes, ordinances), request hotline or municipal data, and, for claims about business impact, look for economic reports or surveys of affected shop owners to corroborate the extent of harm.

Explicação

A identificação de declarações factuais e opinativas é essencial para distinguir entre informações verificáveis e interpretações subjetivas. As fontes sugeridas para verificação garantem a precisão dos dados apresentados, enquanto as declarações de opinião refletem percepções e previsões que não podem ser comprovadas da mesma forma. Essa análise ajuda a compreender melhor a dinâmica entre fatos e opiniões em discussões públicas.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• For a class project, a student compares the role of English in two countries. The project notes that English is an…
• A comparative report for a language exhibition presents this fictional survey of residents aged 15 or older: “In…
• During a renovation, a technician writes in a report: “A cold draft entered through a gap beneath the door.” Later, an…
• Em uma reportagem sobre animais, lê-se: “At dusk, a bat flew out of the cave.” Em uma notícia esportiva, aparece: “The…
• At an international sailing event, 18 crews from 12 countries took part. English was the official language for race…
• Editorial excerpt, adapted for educational use from data published by UNESCO in 2024: "UNESCO reported that 251 million…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação