Read the paragraph below (from a local news opinion column). Then: identify two factual statements and two…

Questão

Read the paragraph below (from a local news opinion column). Then: identify two factual statements and two opinion statements in the paragraph; for each fact say how you would verify it; for each opinion explain one reasonable challenge. Write your response in English (approx. 100–150 words). Paragraph: "The county hospital reported 200 flu cases last week. Many parents worry that school classrooms remain unsafe because the district did not improve ventilation. Health experts note vaccinations rose by 10% this season, but some residents insist the school system prioritizes budget cuts over students' health."

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer (example): Facts: (1) "The county hospital reported 200 flu cases last week" — verify with the hospital’s report or public health data. (2) "Vaccinations rose by 10% this season" — check official immunization records or health department statistics. Opinions: (1) "Many parents worry that school classrooms remain unsafe" — this reports concern but is about perception; challenge by surveying parents or checking safety metrics. (2) "The school system prioritizes budget cuts over students' health" — evaluative claim; challenge by examining budget documents and spending on health-related upgrades.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente dois fatos e duas opiniões, além de fornecer métodos de verificação para os fatos e desafios razoáveis para as opiniões. Isso demonstra uma compreensão das diferenças entre informações objetivas e subjetivas, além de mostrar habilidades analíticas ao avaliar as afirmações. A estrutura da resposta é clara e concisa, facilitando a compreensão do leitor.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Excerpt: “Recent municipal health reports show teenage vaping rose from 8% to 21% in five years; hospital admissions for…
• Using the same excerpt above, write a 250–300 word essay in English that analyzes how the author’s lexical choices…
• Analyze the sentence: "Mistakes were made during the implementation of the new language policy." What discursive…
• "Our language is under attack—foreign words are destroying our culture." Which argumentative resource best describes…
• Read the sentence: "As a physician, I recommend this vaccine." Which rhetorical appeal is the speaker using primarily?
• Read: "When English is labeled 'standard,' speakers of other varieties are often treated as less competent. Schools and…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação