Plan an argumentative essay in English responding to the prompt: “Local public libraries should remain open…

Questão

Plan an argumentative essay in English responding to the prompt: “Local public libraries should remain open after school hours to support student learning.” Produce: a one-sentence thesis, three supporting claims (one sentence each) with the specific type of evidence you would research for each (do not invent figures), and a one-sentence rebuttal to a likely opposing claim.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Thesis: Local public libraries should remain open after school because they provide equitable access to study resources, safe supervised spaces, and targeted academic support that schools alone cannot offer. 1) Claim: Libraries increase equitable access to learning materials; Evidence to research: local checkout statistics, catalog access logs, and surveys showing students’ home internet/device access. 2) Claim: After-school hours provide supervised spaces that improve study time and reduce unsupervised risk; Evidence to research: community attendance records, local youth-safety reports, and testimonials from librarians and parents. 3) Claim: Libraries offer targeted academic support such as tutoring, homework help, and literacy programs; Evidence to research: program schedules, tutor session counts, and before/after student performance summaries from participating programs. Rebuttal (one sentence): While some argue keeping libraries open is costly, targeted partnerships with schools and volunteers can offset expenses and yield measurable gains in student achievement and wellbeing.

Explicação

A estrutura apresentada é clara e lógica, começando com uma tese forte que define a posição do autor. Os três argumentos são bem fundamentados, cada um com uma sugestão de evidência específica que pode ser pesquisada, o que demonstra um planejamento eficaz para sustentar a argumentação. A inclusão de uma refutação mostra a capacidade de antecipar e responder a objeções, fortalecendo ainda mais a argumentação geral.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• School notice: SCIENCE FAIR Friday, 3 p.m., in the school gym. Visitors can see student projects and talk to the…
• “We need a small leaflet for the community fridge,” Maya told her group. “It will help families waste less food at…
• “Books can travel from one reader to another,” says Maya, a volunteer at the neighborhood library. On Saturday, the…
• On the kitchen notice board, a teacher left a message for the class: the local community center will publish a short…
• List three short paragraph topics (each 2–4 words) to organize a short text about a school festival.
• You will write a short informational text (about 120–150 words) for younger students about how to care for classroom…

Todas as questões de Planejamento do texto: brainstorming