After your group shared different drafts on a local recycling campaign, write a 140–180 word evaluative…

Questão

After your group shared different drafts on a local recycling campaign, write a 140–180 word evaluative paragraph in English. Explain how opposing viewpoints strengthened or weakened the group's final argument and propose one concrete revision.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

The group's drafts showed useful variety: some members emphasized environmental data while others highlighted community benefits. The data-based drafts strengthened credibility by providing facts and local statistics, while personal-experience perspectives made the message more relatable to neighbors. However, opposing claims sometimes weakened the final argument because they used different tones and repeated similar examples without synthesis, which created repetition and mixed emphasis. To improve the group text, combine the strongest elements: open with a concise statistic about local waste, follow with one short personal testimony to build empathy, then present a clear proposal of three specific actions residents can take. Finally, add a brief sentence addressing a common counterargument (for example, "Some say recycling is costly, but local programs reduce long-term expenses") to show balance. This revision keeps evidence and voice, reduces repetition, and clarifies the campaign's practical steps.

Explicação

A resposta apresenta uma análise clara dos pontos fortes e fracos das diferentes abordagens dos membros do grupo, demonstrando como a diversidade de perspectivas pode impactar a argumentação final. Além disso, sugere uma revisão concreta que integra os melhores elementos das contribuições, melhorando a coesão e a eficácia da mensagem. A inclusão de uma resposta a um contra-argumento também fortalece a argumentação ao mostrar uma compreensão das objeções potenciais.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Em um submarino, a tripulação lê uma nota de operação em inglês. Depois, dois tripulantes conversam sobre a informação…
• At home, Nina and her brother read the same short story about a lost dog. Nina thinks the dog ran away because it was…
• A student reads this short science text on a tablet: “Coral reefs are home to many sea animals. When ocean water stays…
• A group of friends reads a short story on a reading app. In their chat, Mia writes, “I liked the ending because the main…
• After reading a short story, Mia says: “I should share my opinion only if everyone agrees with me.” Leo thinks readers…
• At a book club, Mia says, “I liked the story because the main character was brave.” Leo replies, “I agree, and I also…

Todas as questões de Partilha de leitura