Read the short opinion paragraph from a local news column below and complete the tasks. Excerpt: "Since Mayor…

Questão

Read the short opinion paragraph from a local news column below and complete the tasks. Excerpt: "Since Mayor Blake opened the new bike lanes on March 3, downtown traffic delays rose by 12% and two delivery routes were rerouted. In my view, the mayor's plan favors cyclists over small businesses and is a reckless move that will hurt the local economy." Tasks: 1) Identify two factual statements and two opinion statements. 2) Explain how you distinguished facts from opinions. 3) State the author's main claim and evaluate whether the facts given support it.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: 1) Facts: (a) "Mayor Blake opened the new bike lanes on March 3." (b) "Downtown traffic delays rose by 12% and two delivery routes were rerouted." 2) Distinction: Facts are verifiable (dates, percentages, route changes); opinions express judgment or belief (words like "favors," "reckless," "will hurt"). 3) Main claim: The author argues the plan prioritizes cyclists over small businesses and will harm the local economy. Evaluation: The stated facts (date, 12% increase, rerouted routes) document changes but do not by themselves prove economic harm; stronger support would require business revenue data, surveys, or longer-term trends linking delays to sales declines.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente as declarações factuais e opinativas, demonstrando a capacidade de diferenciar entre informações verificáveis e julgamentos pessoais. Além disso, a avaliação da alegação principal é fundamentada, reconhecendo que, embora os fatos apresentados indiquem mudanças no tráfego, não fornecem evidências diretas de impacto econômico negativo. Essa análise crítica é essencial para entender a relação entre dados e argumentos em um texto opinativo.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Em um submarino, a tripulação lê uma nota de operação em inglês. Depois, dois tripulantes conversam sobre a informação…
• At home, Nina and her brother read the same short story about a lost dog. Nina thinks the dog ran away because it was…
• A student reads this short science text on a tablet: “Coral reefs are home to many sea animals. When ocean water stays…
• A group of friends reads a short story on a reading app. In their chat, Mia writes, “I liked the ending because the main…
• After reading a short story, Mia says: “I should share my opinion only if everyone agrees with me.” Leo thinks readers…
• At a book club, Mia says, “I liked the story because the main character was brave.” Leo replies, “I agree, and I also…

Todas as questões de Partilha de leitura