Excerpt: "The transportation report shows bus ridership dropped 8% last year. Some analysts claim this decline…

Questão

Excerpt: "The transportation report shows bus ridership dropped 8% last year. Some analysts claim this decline proves the new route schedule is failing to serve commuters." Explain two textual cues that indicate a claim is likely a factual statement and two cues that indicate a claim is likely an opinion. For each factual cue you name, propose one concrete way to verify that factual claim.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Factual cues (examples from the excerpt): 1) Specific numerical data: "dropped 8% last year." Verification: check the transportation report or official ridership datasets for that period and compare figures. 2) Attribution to an authoritative source: "The transportation report shows..." Verification: locate the cited report (agency website or public records) and confirm the cited statement and context. Opinion cues (examples from the excerpt): 1) Evaluative language: "failing to serve commuters" — expresses a judgment about performance rather than a measurable fact. 2) Hedging/attribution to people: "Some analysts claim..." — shows the statement is an interpretation or claim by commentators, not a direct, verifiable measurement. Using these cues, a reader distinguishes facts (checkable data or named sources) from opinions (value words, judgments, or attributions) and verifies facts by consulting primary data or official documents.

Explicação

A resposta identifica claramente os elementos que caracterizam afirmações factuais e opiniões, utilizando exemplos concretos do texto. Além disso, propõe métodos de verificação para as afirmações factuais, o que demonstra uma compreensão prática de como validar informações. A distinção entre dados verificáveis e interpretações subjetivas é fundamental para a análise crítica de textos.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• Discuss the importance of expressing opinions respectfully in discussions.
• What is your opinion on the impact of social media on communication?
• At school, Ana reads sentences about dogs. Which sentence presents a fact?
• Discuss the importance of using counterarguments in persuasive writing. Provide examples of how they can strengthen an…
• In a hypothetical local news report, the town library recorded 120 visitors on Saturday in April and 180 on Saturday in…
• For a class project, a student compares the role of English in two countries. The project notes that English is an…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação