Read the short news excerpt below and respond as instructed. Excerpt: "The city council approved a new curfew…

Questão

Read the short news excerpt below and respond as instructed. Excerpt: "The city council approved a new curfew last night to reduce late-night disturbances. Police records show complaints about noise dropped by 20% in the affected neighborhood after prior curfews. The mayor said the measure will restore community safety and called opponents irresponsible. Critics argue the curfew violates personal freedoms and serves political interests." Task: Identify which sentences are facts and which are opinions; justify each classification by citing wording or verifiability. Then state the author's likely stance and propose one concise revision to make the excerpt more neutral for a news report.

✍️ Questão dissertativa: veja abaixo a resposta esperada e a explicação.

Resposta esperada

Model answer: Facts — Sentence 1 (council approved curfew): verifiable event; Sentence 2 (police records, 20% drop): verifiable data, cited source. Opinions — Sentence 3 ("will restore community safety" and "called opponents irresponsible"): evaluative claims and insulting characterization; Sentence 4 ("violates personal freedoms" / "serves political interests"): value judgments and attribution of motive. Author's stance seems mildly pro-curfew because the mayor's evaluative claims are presented without qualification while opponents are framed strongly. Revision to neutralize: attribute evaluations and add sourcing — e.g., change "called opponents irresponsible" to "said some opponents are irresponsible" and indicate the source for the critics' claim or present both views with evidence.

Explicação

A classificação entre fatos e opiniões é baseada na verificação das informações apresentadas; fatos são dados que podem ser confirmados, enquanto opiniões envolvem julgamentos e interpretações. A análise da postura do autor revela um viés a favor da medida, evidenciado pela forma como as declarações do prefeito são apresentadas. A proposta de revisão visa equilibrar a apresentação das informações, garantindo que ambas as perspectivas sejam tratadas de maneira justa e fundamentada.

Raio-X da questão

Questões parecidas com resolução

• In a hypothetical local news report, the town library recorded 120 visitors on Saturday in April and 180 on Saturday in…
• For a class project, a student compares the role of English in two countries. The project notes that English is an…
• A comparative report for a language exhibition presents this fictional survey of residents aged 15 or older: “In…
• During a renovation, a technician writes in a report: “A cold draft entered through a gap beneath the door.” Later, an…
• Em uma reportagem sobre animais, lê-se: “At dusk, a bat flew out of the cave.” Em uma notícia esportiva, aparece: “The…
• At an international sailing event, 18 crews from 12 countries took part. English was the official language for race…

Todas as questões de Recursos de argumentação